I had read some positive feedback about Supercat and really wanted to try it out for myself. At £6 it's a very reasonably priced liner so I took the plunge a couple of weeks ago and plonked it in my Boots basket.
I have always worn liner on my upper lid but I'm relatively new to winged liner so I bought this to practice with.
I was using Rimmel London Waterproof Gel Eyeliner but found that although it stays put the colour does fade towards the end of the day or night. To be honest I really wouldn't want to try and touch up liner 'mid night out' as the results would be catastrophic. I had high hopes that Supercat would last a little longer.
This liquid black eyeliner pen should be easy to apply with a firm nib. It's gentle on the eyelid but I did struggle with precision compared to my Rimmel liner that comes with a little brush in the lid. I prefer a skinny black line and used the fine point as suggested on the box. At first I did find this tricky but after a few days I got the hang of it. The colour is very black when first applied and doesn't need to be built up. However I found that it did seem to spread into my eyeshadow and one day I got home from work to find the outer edges smudged all over my face.
In theory Supercat should be the best but in reality I have already headed back to the Rimmel...
Have you tried Supercat? What's your favourite liner?